New Supreme Court Decision Makes Clear the Standard for Introducing Medical Evidence in Tennessee Personal Injury Cases

New Supreme Court Decision Makes Clear the Standard for Introducing Medical Evidence in Tennessee Personal Injury CasesA recent Tennessee Supreme Court decision (Jean Dedmon v. Debbie Steelman, et al.) made clear that a plaintiff’s lawyer can introduce hospital, doctor, and other medical bills based on the initial amount the medical care provider charged, and not the discounted amount an insurance company paid. The difference is critical because many juries, judges, and arbitrators base the amount of pain and suffering victims have on the dollar amount of their medical bills. Additionally, the lower amount also means insurance companies pay less than what is really owed – thus hurting the medical provider.

Confusion about which bills (the original bills or the discounted bills) could be introduced in personal injury cases began with another Tennessee case, West v. Shelby County Healthcare Corporation.  In that case, the hospital sought to obtain a lien against a patient who had not paid the hospital for medical services. A lien is essentially a security interest in a person’s property to ensure that a debt is paid.

Medical providers normally contract with insurance companies to pay a discounted price. They do this because they know the insurance companies have the money. Collecting from patients directly requires a lot of legal work. Getting the insurance company to pay saves the hospital expensive collection costs.

The West decision held that the hospital could only obtain a lien for the discounted amount – the amount hospitals routinely accept from insurance companies. The Supreme Court based their decision on their interpretation of Tennessee’s lien laws.

Insurance companies then tried to use the West decision to limit the amount of medical claims submitted in personal injury cases to the discounted amount.

  • A lower trial court agreed with the insurance company that only the discounted amount could be introduced.
  • The Tennessee Court of Appeals reversed the lower court and held that only the higher original medical bill could be introduced (whether the injured plaintiff had insurance or not). It did, however, say that the defense could introduce the discounted bills to show the original higher bills were not reasonable.
  • The Tennessee Supreme Court agreed with the Tennessee Court of Appeals by ruling that the higher rate should be introduced AND that the insurance company could NOT introduce the discounted rate – even to show the insurance bill was unreasonable.

The Supreme Court also denied an effort by insurance companies to argue that medical services should be reviewed based on the fair market value of the services – a backdoor way of arguing that just the discounted rates should be introduced. The Supreme Court rejected the fair market value approach. It held that if the defendant did not pay the plaintiff’s medical bills, the discounted amount cannot be used. Additionally, the Supreme Court ruled, the defendant cannot mention that a plaintiff has insurance because it might prejudice the jury into thinking the plaintiff was already compensated for their injuries.

At the Rocky McElhaney Law Firm, our personal injuries contest every attempt by insurance companies to deny your claim or to reduce the amount of damages that you are due. Our Gladiators in Suits fight to get accident victims and the families of deceased victims every dollar they deserve. To talk with a truck accident lawyer in Nashville, Hendersonville, or Knoxville, please call us at 615-246-5549 or complete our contact form to make an appointment. We represent plaintiffs on a contingency fee basis.

Badges

What Clients Say About Us

“You and your staff again are amazing…”

"As much as I love all the "thank you's" my friend is giving me for recommending you, I of course cannot take all the credit. You and your staff again are amazing and when I can, I wil refer you always. My friend is overwhelmed (her exact words) for how well you took care of her and her daughter."

Kerry W.

Rocky McElhaney Law Firm
5.0
2015-02-06T15:32:17+00:00

Kerry W.

"As much as I love all the "thank you's" my friend is giving me for recommending you, I of course cannot take all the credit. You and your staff again are amazing and when I can, I wil refer you always. My friend is overwhelmed (her exact words) for how well you took care of her and her daughter."

“Rocky McElhaney Law Firm went above and beyond the call of duty “

"5 stars! To whom it may concern: Rocky McElhaney Law Firm went above and beyond the call of duty when it came to handling my case. Rocky McElhaney and Russell Belk were there for me 100% of the way."

Linda S.

Rocky McElhaney Law Firm
5.0
2015-02-06T15:34:24+00:00

Linda S.

"5 stars! To whom it may concern: Rocky McElhaney Law Firm went above and beyond the call of duty when it came to handling my case. Rocky McElhaney and Russell Belk were there for me 100% of the way."

“…You are not just a number, but a name.”

"5 stars! This is the greatest Law firm I have ever seen. They make you feel like you are being taken care of and you are not just a number, but a name. They are very concerned with your every need. Rocky we love your LAW FIRM!!"

Mary T.

Rocky McElhaney Law Firm
5.0
2015-02-06T16:39:44+00:00

Mary T.

"5 stars! This is the greatest Law firm I have ever seen. They make you feel like you are being taken care of and you are not just a number, but a name. They are very concerned with your every need. Rocky we love your LAW FIRM!!"

“I would like to express my sincere gratitude…”

"5 stars! I would like to express my sincere gratitude to you and all the attorneys who handled my case from The Rocky McElhaney Law Firm for your excellent representation in my case. Words cannot express my heartfelt thanks for your outstanding professionalism, expertise, and legal consultation."

Eddie H.

Rocky McElhaney Law Firm
5.0
2015-02-06T16:39:03+00:00

Eddie H.

"5 stars! I would like to express my sincere gratitude to you and all the attorneys who handled my case from The Rocky McElhaney Law Firm for your excellent representation in my case. Words cannot express my heartfelt thanks for your outstanding professionalism, expertise, and legal consultation."

“We could never begin to thank you for all of your help.”

"We could never begin to thank you for all of your help. We always refer folks to you and will continue as you are, “The Man!” We treasure your friendship and are so proud to say that Rocky McElhaney is our lawyer!"

Bobby and Beck P.

Rocky McElhaney Law Firm
5.0
2015-02-06T15:33:42+00:00

Bobby and Beck P.

"We could never begin to thank you for all of your help. We always refer folks to you and will continue as you are, “The Man!” We treasure your friendship and are so proud to say that Rocky McElhaney is our lawyer!"

“Rocky McElhaney Law firm is filled with great people…”

"5 stars! If you’re looking for a team of great attorney’s, then you’ve reached the ones and no longer need to search. Rocky McElhaney Law firm is filled with great people that are empathetic, and will fight for you like they are fighting for themselves! Call them up and see for yourselves!"

Phillip H.

Rocky McElhaney Law Firm
5.0
2015-02-06T16:37:49+00:00

Phillip H.

"5 stars! If you’re looking for a team of great attorney’s, then you’ve reached the ones and no longer need to search. Rocky McElhaney Law firm is filled with great people that are empathetic, and will fight for you like they are fighting for themselves! Call them up and see for yourselves!"
5
6
Text Us615-246-5549